The first white elephant I ever played was at a neighbor’s Christmas party. The rules hadn’t been agreed and so half the room thought you could steal as many times as you liked. The other half thought it was one steal per gift.
A scented candle changed hands something like nine times as the host was going through her phone looking for official rules that don’t exist.
Most people have played a gift exchange games but no two groups play by the same rules. The arguing starts the when someone reaches for a gift that was just stolen.
Read More: 26 Christmas Party Games for Adults, Families and Kids
So here are 24 white elephant and gift exchange games with clear rules you can read out before you start. There’s classic white elephant with the steal rules spelled out plus twists that speed it up or make it fairer. You’ll also find dice and card games, Secret Santa games, gift swaps for kids and a few for adults only.
Each game has what you need, how to play, how many players and roughly how long it takes.
How to Pick a Gift Exchange Game
The right game depends mostly on how many people are coming and how much time you’ve got. Making some decisions before the party will mean you avoid any arguing on the night.
- Count your players. Steal games like white elephant are at their best with 8 to 20 people. If there’s less than 6 there’s not enough to steal. More than 25 and the game drags and people at the end of the order wait an hour for their turn.
- Set a budget and put it on the invitation. $15 to $25 is the usual range for friends and coworkers. Family exchanges sometimes go higher, kids’ swaps lower.
- Decide if it’s gag gifts or real gifts. Both are fun but mixing them means someone brings a nice bluetooth speaker and goes home with a singing fish. Say which one it is up front.
- Give yourself enough time. Plan on about 2 minutes per player for white elephant. Dice and card games run on a timer so they’re easier to fit into a busy party.
- Think about who might feel left out. If budgets are tight in your group, a regift swap or a thrift store challenge keeps the cost down for everyone.
- Make it optional at work. Some people don’t want to buy a gift or have it opened in front of the whole office.
If you’re still planning the rest of the evening our Christmas party ideas and themes will help you pick a theme, and you can match the gift exchange to it.
White Elephant and Its Best Twists
White elephant is the game most people mean when they say gift exchange. You’ll also hear it called Yankee Swap or Dirty Santa, depending on where you grew up, and each name tends to come with slightly different house rules. Start with the classic version then pick a twist if your group has played it a hundred times and want something different.
1. Classic White Elephant
Everyone brings one wrapped gift and goes home with one gift but almost never the one they wanted. The steals are what make it fun because a gift that looked boring in the pile suddenly becomes the thing three people are fighting over.
What you need: One wrapped gift per player (all under the same budget) and numbered slips of paper in a bowl or hat.
How to play:
- Everyone puts their gift in the pile and draws a number.
- Player 1 picks a gift from the pile and opens it so everyone can see.
- Each player after that can either open a new gift from the pile or steal a gift someone has already opened.
- If your gift gets stolen, you can open a new gift or steal from someone else. You can’t steal back the gift that was just taken from you.
- A gift is frozen after its third steal. Whoever holds it then keeps it.
- The game ends when the last gift from the pile has been opened.
Players: 6 to 25
Time: About 2 minutes per player, so 30 to 45 minutes for a group of 15 to 20
Tip: Read the rules out loud before anyone draws a number and agree on the steal limit. That one rule causes more arguments than everything else put together.
2. Yankee Swap with a Final Steal
This version fixes the biggest problem with white elephant which is that player 1 gets no choice at all. They open the first gift and then watch everyone else pick over the pile. Here, player 1 gets the last move.
What you need: Same as classic white elephant.
How to play: Play the classic game as normal. Once the last gift is opened player 1 gets one final turn and can swap their gift with any unfrozen gift in the room. The person they swap with doesn’t get to steal again. That’s the end of the game.
Players: 6 to 25
Time: 30 to 45 minutes
Tip: If someone’s gift gets stolen on that last swap let them pick next year’s number first.
3. Steal the Box (Open at the End)
In this twist nobody opens anything until the very end. You steal wrapped boxes based on size, shape, weight and how suspicious the wrapping looks. It’s quicker than classic white elephant and works well with gag gifts because the reveal happens all at once.
What you need: Wrapped gifts and numbered slips. Encourage people to disguise their gifts (a small gift in a big box, a bottle wrapped in a pillow).
How to play: Draw numbers. On your turn take a wrapped gift from the pile or steal a wrapped gift from someone else. Anyone who loses a gift takes another from the pile or steals a different one. Shaking and weighing gifts is allowed, opening is not. When the pile is empty, everyone opens their gift at the same time.
Players: 6 to 30
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Ask everyone to bring their gift in a gift bag with tissue paper on top or wrap it in plain brown paper, so nobody can spot their own gift and avoid it.
4. Regift White Elephant
Everyone brings something they already own and don’t want. It costs nothing, clears out a cupboard and the gifts are usually funnier than anything you could buy.
What you need: One wrapped item from home per person. Set a simple rule: it has to be clean, unused or in good shape and something a person could plausibly want.
How to play: Play by classic white elephant rules. When someone opens a gift the person who brought it can tell the story of where it came from if they want to.
Players: 6 to 25
Time: 30 to 45 minutes
Tip: Agree beforehand that nobody can be offended if their old gift shows up. Regifts have a way of finding their original giver.
5. Theme White Elephant
Pick a theme and every gift has to fit it. It’s easier to shop for than “anything under $20” and the gifts end up being more useful.
What you need: A theme on the invitation, a wrapped gift per player and numbered slips.
Theme ideas that work:
- Something red (or any color)
- Things you’d use on a cozy night in
- Kitchen gadgets
- As Seen on TV products
- Something from your hometown or a local shop
- Self care
- Something that costs exactly $10
- Gifts that start with the first letter of your name
How to play: Same as classic white elephant.
Players: 6 to 25
Time: 30 to 45 minutes
Tip: “Things you’d use on a cozy night in” is a good theme for mixed groups. Almost any gift fits, from socks to cocoa to a candle, and it’s hard to get it wrong.
6. Rock Paper Scissors Steal
In this version a steal has to be earned. If you want someone’s gift, you challenge them to rock paper scissors. Win and it’s yours. Lose and you have to open a new gift from the pile.
What you need: Same as classic white elephant.
How to play: Play the classic game, but every steal becomes a best-of-three rock paper scissors match between the stealer and the holder. If the holder wins they keep the gift and the challenger opens a new one. A gift that survives two challenges is frozen.
Players: 6 to 25
Time: 30 to 40 minutes
Tip: This one is good with competitive groups. The person holding the best gift gets to defend it so they don’t feel robbed.
7. Ornament Exchange
The same rules as white elephant, but every gift is a Christmas ornament. It’s a good fit for family parties because the gifts are small and cheap, and everyone goes home with something to hang on the tree.
What you need: One wrapped ornament per person (set a limit like $10 to $15) and numbered slips. A set of small Christmas gift boxes keeps the ornaments safe while they’re being passed around.
12 Pack Christmas Gift Boxes with Lids – Large 17″ (4″ Deep) & 14″ (2″ Deep)
How to play: Play by classic white elephant rules, with a limit of two steals per ornament.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Ask people to write the year and the party name on a tag tied to the ornament. Years later it’s the ornament that gets a story when it comes out of the box.
Dice and Card Gift Exchange Games
These games use dice, cards or a story to decide who gets which gift. They’re faster than white elephant and work well when the group is too big for everyone to take a turn.
8. Gift Exchange Dice Game
Two rounds of dice decide where every gift ends up and the second round runs on a timer so nobody knows who’ll end up with what until the buzzer goes.
Giant Soft Cubes Dot 2/pk 5 Inch
What you need: One wrapped gift per player, two dice (or a pair of jumbo foam dice which are easier to see across the room) and a timer.
How to play:
- Put the gifts in the middle. Players sit in a circle and pass the dice around.
- Round 1: Roll the dice. If you roll doubles, take a gift from the middle. Keep going around the circle until every gift has been claimed. Some people will have two or three gifts, and some will have none.
- Round 2: Set a timer for 5 to 10 minutes and keep passing the dice. Roll a 7 and you steal a gift from anyone. Roll doubles and you pass one of your gifts to the left. Roll an 11 and you swap any two gifts in the room.
- When the timer goes off the gifts stop moving. Anyone holding more than one gift gives the extras to people with none.
- Everyone opens their gift.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 20 to 25 minutes
Tip: Write the round 2 rules on a card and pass it around with the dice. Otherwise, half the table will forget what a 7 means.
9. Card Draw Gift Exchange
Players hold playing cards and the host draws from a second deck to decide who picks next. It’s quick and you can make it as long or short as you like.
What you need: Two decks of playing cards, one wrapped gift per player. A pack of Christmas playing cards suits the season.
Christmas Playing Cards, 2 Decks of Cards
How to play: Deal one deck out evenly so everyone holds a few cards. The host shuffles the second deck and draws cards one at a time calling each one out. Whoever holds the matching card picks a gift from the pile, or once the pile is empty, steals one from anyone. Keep going until the host has drawn the whole deck. Then everyone opens what they’re holding.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 15 to 20 minutes
Tip: For a shorter game, take out the same half of the cards (say, all the clubs and spades) from both decks before you start.
10. Left Right Gift Exchange
Everyone sits in a circle with a wrapped gift on their lap. The host reads a story full of the words “left” and “right” and the gifts move every time one of those words comes up. When the story ends, you keep whatever’s in your hands.
What you need: One wrapped gift per player and a short story using “left” and “right” a lot. Write your own about the group or search for a printable left right Christmas story.
How to play: Each player holds one gift. The host reads the story slowly. Every time they say “left” everyone passes their gift to the left. Every time they say “right” everyone passes to the right. Speed up as the story goes on. When the story ends everyone opens the gift they’re holding.
Players: 8 to 30
Time: 10 minutes
Tip: Write the story about your own family or office (“Grandpa LEFT the turkey in the oven, which wasn’t RIGHT..”). People will listen to the story as closely as they watch the gifts.
11. Gift Exchange Trivia
Answer a question right and you get to pick a gift or steal one. It slows the steals down and everyone else gets to shout answers.
What you need: One wrapped gift per player and a list of Christmas trivia questions (movies, songs, traditions), plus a few questions about the group if you know everyone well.
How to play: The host asks a question. The first person to answer correctly opens a gift from the pile or steals one. Anyone who already has a gift can still answer to steal. Once every gift is opened run five more questions as steal only rounds. Then the game ends.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Keep the questions easy. The fun is in the steals, so you don’t want people stuck on a hard question for five minutes.
12. Let’s Make a Deal Swap
The host plays game show presenter and tempts people into swaps. “Keep your gift, or trade it for whatever’s in this box?” Most people trade even when they shouldn’t.
What you need: One wrapped gift per player plus three or four extra “deal” items. These can be a mix of good things (a gift card, a bottle of wine) and bad ones (a single sock, a can of beans).
How to play: Hand out gifts at random and let everyone open them. Then the host walks around the room offering deals: swap your gift for what’s in this envelope, swap with the person on your left or take a mystery box. Each person can say yes or no. After the host has offered everyone at least one deal the game ends and everyone keeps what they’ve got.
Players: 8 to 25
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Make the host someone loud who enjoys the attention. This one depends on a good presenter.
Secret Santa Games
Secret Santa works when you want everyone to get a gift picked for them. Names get drawn ahead of time so each person shops for one person in the group. It suits families and offices where people know each other well enough to buy something they’ll like.
13. Classic Secret Santa with a Guessing Round
The classic Secret Santa is easy to set up. Adding a guessing round at the end means that opening the gifts turns into a game too.
What you need: Everyone’s name on a slip in a hat (or a free online name drawing tool if people are far apart), a budget and a short wish list from each person.
Related reading
How to play: Draw names a few weeks before the party. Everyone buys a gift for the person they drew and labels it with that person’s name only. At the party one person at a time opens their gift and gets one guess at who their Secret Santa is. If they guess right the Santa reveals themselves. If they guess wrong the Santa stays secret until everyone has opened their gift and had a guess and then all the remaining Santas reveal at once.
Players: 4 to 30
Time: 2 to 3 minutes per person on the night
Tip: Ask everyone to fill in a short card when names are drawn: favorite snack, favorite color, a hobby, one thing they’d never use. It saves a lot of bad guesses at the store.
14. Secret Santa Clue Game
Each Santa writes three clues about who they are, from vague to obvious. The person opening the gift reads them out one at a time and tries to guess with as few clues as they can.
What you need: Secret Santa gifts and three clue cards attached to each gift.
How to play: Each Santa writes three clues about themselves. The first should be hard (“I’ve been here longer than you”), the second a little easier (“I’m not a coffee person”) and the third close to a giveaway (“I sit by the window”). The recipient reads clue one and makes a guess. If they’re wrong, they read clue two and guess again, then clue three. Guess on the first clue and you get a point. The person with the most points at the end wins a small prize.
Players: 4 to 20
Time: 3 minutes per person
Tip: This works best when people know each other well, like a family or a team that’s worked together for a while.
15. Want, Need, Wear, Read Exchange
This one borrows the four gift rule some families use for kids: something you want, something you need, something to wear and something to read. Each person draws a name and a category and the category tells them what to buy.
What you need: Names in one hat and the four categories written on slips in another (repeat them so there’s a category for every person).
How to play: When names are drawn each person also draws a category. They buy a gift in that category for the person they drew. At the party the recipient has to guess the category before opening. Needs are usually the hardest to guess because a need can be almost anything.
Players: 4 to 20
Time: 2 minutes per person
Tip: This works well for a family with a mix of ages. The categories make it easier to shop for a teenager or a grandparent you don’t see much.
16. Secret Santa Week
Instead of one gift on the day of the party each Santa leaves small surprises for their person over several days, then gives one main gift at the party. It’s a good choice for an office where people see each other every day.
What you need: Names drawn at least a week ahead and a budget for the small gifts (a few dollars each) and the main gift.
How to play: For the week before the party each Santa secretly leaves a small treat for their person every day or two, like a candy cane on their desk, a note or a coffee. At the party everyone gives their main gift and the recipient guesses who their Santa was.
Players: 6 to 30
Time: One week, plus about 2 minutes per person at the party
Tip: Set a total budget for the week. Otherwise someone always goes overboard on day one and the rest of the office feels like they have to keep up.
Gift Exchange Games for Kids
Steal games can end in tears with younger kids especially when a favorite toy gets taken. These games still have the surprise of a gift exchange but everyone gets something and the stealing is either gentle or doesn’t happen at all.
17. Santa’s Sack Grab Bag
All the gifts go into one big sack and each child reaches in and pulls one out. It’s the simplest gift exchange there is, and it’s the best choice for kids under 6.
What you need: One wrapped gift per child (a $5 to $10 limit works for most kids’ parties) and a large Santa sack or a pillowcase.
Christmas Large Gift Bags 31″ x 27″ with Cord Drawstring
How to play: Have the kids sit in a circle. One at a time each child reaches into the sack without looking and pulls out a gift. Once everyone has one, they all open at the same time.
Players: 3 to 20 kids
Time: 10 minutes
Tip: Ask parents to bring gifts that would suit any child, like art supplies, puzzles, books or small building sets. It avoids the disappointment of a toddler toy ending up with a 7-year-old.
18. Musical Gift Pass
Kids pass wrapped gifts around the circle while music plays. When it stops, they hold whatever they’ve got. After a few rounds everyone opens what they’re holding.
What you need: One wrapped gift per child, Christmas music and someone on the pause button.
How to play: Each child starts with a gift. Play music and the gifts move around the circle until the music stops. Do five or six rounds, changing direction each time. After the last round everyone opens the gift they’re holding.
Players: 5 to 20 kids
Time: 10 minutes
Tip: Make the last round the longest so the kids can’t keep track of where their own gift went.
19. Gift Exchange Scavenger Hunt
Instead of picking from a pile each child follows a trail of clues to find a hidden gift. It takes some setting up but it keeps older kids busy for a good half hour.
What you need: One wrapped gift per child (hidden around the house or yard) plus a short trail of 3 or 4 clue cards for each gift. Color code the clues so each child follows their own trail.
How to play: Give each child their first clue card in their color. They follow the clues to the next hiding place and the last clue leads to a gift. Everyone opens their gift once all the kids have found theirs.
Players: 3 to 12 kids
Time: 20 to 30 minutes, plus setup
Tip: Rhyming clues are easy to write and kids love reading them out. “Where we keep the cold milk is where you’ll look next” works for a 6-year-old.
20. Christmas Bingo Gift Swap
Every time a child gets bingo they pick a gift. Later winners can pick a new gift or steal one that’s been opened so there’s a little white elephant fun without the pressure.
What you need: Christmas bingo cards, markers (candy works), one wrapped gift per child and a caller.
How to play: Play bingo as normal. The first child to get a line picks and opens a gift then sits out while the others keep playing. Clear the cards after each win and keep going until every child has a gift. Once five gifts have been opened, each new winner can open a new gift or swap with someone who’s already opened one. Each gift can only be swapped once.
Players: 5 to 20 kids
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Let the youngest kids skip the swap rule. They can just pick from the pile.
If you’re planning the whole party, our Christmas party ideas for kids has themes and activities to go around the gift exchange.
Gift Exchange Ideas for Adults
These swaps work for a group of friends, a book club or a dinner party where everyone’s an adult. The gifts tend to be more personal and they’re good conversation starters.
21. Blind Date with a Book Swap
Everyone brings a book they love, wrapped in brown paper, with a few words on the front describing it. You pick a book from its description alone. In Iceland giving books on Christmas Eve is a long standing tradition and this swap borrows the idea.
What you need: One wrapped book per person a marker for writing on the wrapping and numbered slips.
How to play: On the front of the wrapping, each person writes three to five words or a one-line teaser (“small town, dark secret, can’t put it down”). No titles or authors. Play by white elephant rules: open a new book or steal one that’s been opened. Each book can be stolen twice.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 30 minutes
Tip: Ask everyone to write a short note inside the cover saying why they picked it. People go back to those notes later.
We did this at my book club’s Christmas night and everyone ended up talking about their book for longer than the swap itself took. One friend brought the same book she’d brought the year before and nobody noticed until she said it.
22. Bottle Swap
Each person brings a bottle of wine, a craft beer pack or a spirit under the budget. The bottles go into matching gift bags so nobody knows what’s what until the end.
What you need: One bottle per guest and a set of matching wine gift bags.
DeckTheHalls Christmas Wine Gift Bags for Wine Bottles, 8-Pack with Handles
How to play: Use the Steal the Box rules from game 3. Players take a bag from the pile or steal one and the bags are only opened at the end. For a twist have everyone write tasting notes on a tag (“pairs well with in-laws”) instead of the name of the drink.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Open a couple of the bottles at the party and do a quick taste test.
Please drink responsibly and make sure everyone has a safe way home. Non alcoholic bottles work just as well: sparkling cider, a fancy soda or a bottle of good olive oil or maple syrup all fit in the same bags.
23. Scratch Off Ticket Exchange
Everyone brings $10 to $20 in scratch off lottery tickets, wrapped or in an envelope. Play by white elephant rules, then everyone scratches at the same time. The person who wins the most money gets bragging rights (and maybe buys the next round of cocoa).
What you need: Scratch off tickets, envelopes and coins for scratching. This one is for adults only and the legal age to buy and play varies by state, so check yours first.
How to play: Put each person’s tickets in a sealed envelope. Play by classic white elephant rules, but since envelopes all look the same, the steals are purely based on who looks most pleased with their envelope. When every envelope is claimed, everyone scratches their tickets together.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 20 to 30 minutes
Tip: Agree beforehand whether winnings get split or the winner keeps them.
24. Thrift Store Challenge
Everyone has a $10 budget and has to buy their gift from a thrift store, flea market or garage sale. You get a mix of odd and useful finds and people love telling the story of where they found theirs.
What you need: One thrifted gift per person (wrapped), numbered slips and a small prize for the best find.
How to play: Play by classic white elephant rules. When a gift is opened the person who brought it says where they found it and how much it cost. At the end everyone votes for the best find, and the winner gets a small prize.
Players: 6 to 20
Time: 30 to 45 minutes
Tip: Ask everyone to make sure their thrifted gift is clean and works. A lamp with a frayed cord is funny until someone takes it home.
Gift Ideas for White Elephant and Gift Exchanges
The game only works if the gifts are worth fighting over. A few ideas that tend to get stolen roughly $15 to $25:
- A heated throw blanket
- A cozy pair of slippers or fuzzy socks
- A nice candle
- A board game or card game
- A portable phone charger
- A hot cocoa kit with a mug
- A gift card for a local coffee shop or restaurant
- A cast iron skillet or a good kitchen gadget
- A plant in a nice pot
- Gourmet snacks, like a box of fancy chocolates or hot sauces
Bedsure Heated Blanket Throw Blanket with Preheat Function
For gag gifts go for something that gets a laugh but that someone might secretly want, like a giant novelty mug or a singing fish. Gifts that are just junk tend to get left on the table at the end of the night.
If you’re working to a tight budget our budget Christmas party ideas have more ways to keep costs low for the whole party.
Gift Exchange Rules to Read Out Before You Start
Copy these onto a card or a sign by the gift pile. Most arguments start because someone assumed different rules.
- Budget: $[your budget] per gift.
- One gift per person playing.
- Take a new gift or steal an opened one on your turn.
- No stealing back the gift that was just taken from you.
- A gift is frozen after its third steal.
- Player 1 gets a final swap at the end (if you’re playing Yankee Swap rules).
- Whatever you’re holding at the end is yours. No trading after the game unless both people agree.
READ MORE: Christmas Thank You Messages
Final Thoughts
For most parties pick one main gift exchange game. Classic white elephant suits a group of 8 to 20 adults. The dice game or left right exchange is better for a big crowd or when you’re short on time. For young kids use the Santa’s sack grab bag.
Whichever one you choose put the budget and the steal limit on the invitation and read the rules out before anyone draws a number.
And if someone gave you something you’ll actually keep our funny Christmas wishes and jokes have a few one-liners for a thank-you note.